Telephone: 01539 725855 – no phone menus – talk to a real person today who can direct you to what you need

Protest Vote or Populist Revolution? 7IM Market Commentary

Posted Monday, 07 November 2016, 11.58am

"Conventional politics is dead. Brexit, Donald Trump, ‘Feel the Bern’ Sanders, Italy’s Five Star Movement (founded by a stand-up comedian), Alternative für Deutschland, Austria’s Freedom Party – all are examples of the growing desire among voters to try something radically different. Their actions are thought to express economic and political disadvantage arising from under-representation in national governments and the delegation of sovereignty to supranational organisations. How deep does this undercurrent run, and how concerned should investors be?

As one such supranational organisation, the European Union (EU) is commonly agreed to lack democratic legitimacy. Upon joining the EU, many legislative powers are transferred from national governments to the European Parliament and the Council of Ministers. Meanwhile, voter turnout for European Parliament elections is low and falling. European institutions lack the ability to engage the people on whose behalf they function.

But it’s not just the EU that suffers a democratic deficit. In our own general election, UKIP received 3.9mn votes and won one seat in Parliament. The Scottish National Party, by comparison, received 1.5mn votes, yet won 56 seats. Despite living in a democracy, in spite of our ‘one-man, one-vote’ system, a party that won less than half the votes of its rival was able to win 56 times as much representation.

This anomaly was corrected, with a vengeance, in the subsequent EU referendum. That there is a gulf between the outcomes of ‘direct’ democracy and ‘representative’ democracy should not surprise us. Most developed societies consciously avoid the former in favour of the latter. The significance of the EU referendum is in its indication of the direction of travel. Not surprisingly, voters are keen to preserve their own culture and restrict immigration - if you had offered the British electorate the chance to curtail immigration any time over the last 50 years, they would probably have taken it. More worrying for investors is the implied protest against globalisation."

Click HERE to read the full market commentary.

Chris Darbyshire, 7IM Chief Investment Officer

Find this story and more in our Archive.

© Financial Management Bureau Ltd 2011 - 2017. All rights reserved.
Financial Management Bureau Ltd is a limited company registered in England and Wales. Registered office: Shenstone House, Helsington, Kendal, Cumbria LA8 8AA. Registered number: 02089786